Insights from Brussels - The green change of mood

Is the EU serious about the energy transition?

The EU is keeping a high profile during the ongoing climate talks in Antalya. Overall, EU countries have cut emissions by 39 percent compared to 1990. In the run-up to the climate summit, the European Commission published its annual report on the Union's Climate Action Progress . In it, Dutch climate commissioner Wopke Hoepstra proudly reports that "EU emissions continue to fall, and the use of green technology is becoming increasingly widespread throughout the economy."

Compared to most others, the EU countries have a lot to boast about. However, when you dig into the numbers, the reality quickly becomes more nuanced. You don't have to scroll far past Hoepstra's optimistic opening words before the EU report clearly shows how difficult it will be for the union to reach its own climate goals. Emissions are falling, but not fast enough to reach the goals adopted for 2030. At the current pace, the EU will only reach the goal five years later , in 2035. In another report , released at about the same time, climate scientists concluded that what the world's states have promised to do so far is not enough to avert severe warming. We will see a global temperature rise of 2.7 degrees by the end of the century, even if all this is implemented. The EU is criticized in the report , which claims that the Commission's prestigious project to reduce regulations for European business is weakening climate policy.

On the surface, the EU's climate and energy policy is on a steady course. Most of the green flagships from Ursula von der Leyen's first term as Commission President have been retained and further developed. These include comprehensive plans for green industry, for the electrification of business, transport and households, and for the development of renewable energy and nuclear power. The rhetoric is muted, in line with the fact that climate has fallen in importance on the political agenda in the member states in recent years. When goals and plans nevertheless persist, it is because the new main theme in Brussels, European sovereignty and independence, points in the same direction. In a world with stronger contradictions and less cooperation, states that do not control their own energy supply are in trouble. Their dependence can be exploited for power politics, and the high level of conflict in the world is leading to one fossil fuel price crisis after another. For the EU, the green shift is a way out of this squeeze.

But wanting something is one thing. Doing it is often a completely different matter. When the transition is slower than the EU institutions in Brussels have envisioned, it is partly because the European plans are constantly being pushed against the political reality in the member states. Transition is expensive, and the benefits are often reaped long after the incumbent government's term is over. The pressure from business and the public to do something about high energy prices NOW is understandably great. Despite the summer heat waves, criticism of climate policy is still dominant in many countries. This has resulted in a number of cases of resistance from the capitals to implementing what they have agreed on at the European level.

The EU has decided to postpone several climate measures in recent months. Industry can keep free quotas in the European quota system for four years longer than planned, the new quota system for fuel has been postponed by a year and may be postponed further, and requirements for importers of oil and gas to monitor and report methane emissions were also postponed. Climate requirements for the European car industry were softened last winter, and the EU's sustainability reporting requirements for businesses have been tightened to only apply to the largest companies.

Another question also hangs over the EU representatives in Antalya: What kind of EU will emerge at the upcoming COP? European far-right parties are close to power in a number of member states. In France, Poland, Italy and Spain, green transition is something these parties are skeptical of and in many cases want to reverse. The future of energy and industrial policy will therefore be strongly influenced by the many elections that will take place in key EU countries over the next year.

The answer to the question in the introduction is probably yes. EU leaders are serious about energy transition and emissions cuts. But whether they have the ability to implement it is an open question. And when it is also clear who Europe's most important leaders will be in a year, we are left with an uncertain picture. That does not make the job easier for decision-makers in West Norway and other European regions. What kind of investments, technology and expertise does a company, a school or a municipality needs in the future will be influenced by what this European uncertainty ends up with. The coming year may provide many answers.

Previous
Previous

Vocational education: Want a common direction for Europe

Next
Next

The EU wants to make tourism more sustainable and less vulnerable to mass tourism